He Liked My Posts More Than He Liked Me
There is a very specific kind of man who will watch your Instagram story within three minutes of it going up and still be “too busy” to respond to a text. If you’re a woman who has dated at anypoint in the last decade, you probably know him.
He’s reacting to your stories with the heart eyes. He went deep one night and liked a picturefrom 2024, What he is not doing is calling, making plans, or showing up in any way that requireshim to leave his couch.
We’ve come up with a lot of names for the ways people drift in and out of each other’s livesonline. Ghosting was the first one most of us learned. Breadcrumbing came next, for the people who send just enough to keep you hooked. In 2018, a writer at Man Repeller gave us orbiting,for the person who stops talking to you but keeps watching everything you post. All of these get at something real, but I think there’s a bigger idea underneath them, and it’s modern dating has become parasocial.
Parasocial dating is what happens when engagement starts standing in for effort. Liking a postcosts nothing. Watching a story costs nothing. Sending a fire emoji takes about as muchcommitment as blinking. But because those signals technically count as attention, it becomes very easy to read them as interest. Women tell their friends,“He’s definitely into me, he’s always in my notifications.” And the friend, if she’s a good one.
The term parasocial comes from two researchers, Donald Horton and Richard Wohl, who described the “parasocial relationship” back in 1956. They were writing about television, about the one-sided bond viewers form with hosts and personalities who have no idea they exist. You feel like you know the talk show host because he looks into the camera and talks to you every night. That was the first celebrity phenomenon. Social media fueled it even more. Now everybody has an audience, everybody posts their life in a format built to make strangers feel close, and the people we date have access to a version of us that is always available, always well lit, and never asks for anything.
What makes this so confusing is that the attention is real. He really is watching. He really does remember the trip you posted about last spring. Sometimes that knowledge even carries into a first date, where he asks about things he already saw online, almost like he’s checking whether the person in front of him matches the trailer. Then the date ends and he goes right back to the screen, where things are easier. The texts slow down. The plans stay vague. The likes never stop.
As a person who works PR, I spend my days building public images for brands and people. I know how a feed is constructed to create the feeling of closeness. It still took me longer than I’d like to admit to recognize that I was being consumed like content rather than pursued like a person. And I don’t think I’m unusual in that. When someone engages with you constantly, your brain wants to believe it means something, because in every other context it would.
It would be easy to frame this as something men do to women, and plenty of the stories I hear from friends look exactly like that. But it goes both ways. We build people in our heads from their posts too. A man with a funny caption game and one cute video with his nephew becomes, in our imagination, a fully formed partner, and when the real version shows up a little more awkward or a little less attentive, we go back to the profile instead of dealing with the person .Both sides end up dating avatars. The difference is usually who’s willing to step out from behind theirs.
The reason parasocial dating is so sticky is that it gives one person everything they want at almost no cost. A real relationship has scheduling conflicts and bad days and moments where you have to choose someone else over your own comfort. A feed has none of that. For a certain kind of person, keeping you in their notifications is the relationship, and it’s the most they ever plan to give. It isn’t a step toward something more. It’s the destination.
That also explains why it can hurt in such a strange, quiet way. There’s no fight, no betrayal,nothing dramatic enough to screenshot for the group chat. Just a slow realization that you’re the only one trying to make it real. Being wanted in theory and ignored in practice messes with you,because it makes you wonder what about the in person version of you falls short when the online version clearly doesn’t. The honest answer is usually that nothing falls short. Some people just prefer the highlight reel because the highlight reel can’t ask them to show up.
The fix isn’t logging off forever or pretending social media doesn’t shape how we meet people. It does, and that’s not going away. The fix is refusing to accept attention as a substitute for intention. If someone can find your posts, they can find your number. If they can remember a photo from two years ago, they can remember to ask how your week went. Engagement is a nice gesture. It just isn’t a relationship, and the sooner we stop grading people on their likes, the sooner we can start noticing who actually shows up.
Written by Ketia Jeune



